How AI (Grok) Would Restructure The Current Tax system
How AI (Grok) Would Restructure The Current Tax system
Jamie:
Do you think the current tax system is logical in the way it's structured?
Grok:
The current U.S. tax system is a patchwork of political compromises, economic theories, and 100+ years of incremental changes. Is it “logical” in the sense of being clean, consistent, simple, and economically efficient?
No, not really.
The current system is neither elegantly logical nor completely insane. It’s a Frankenstein monster that mostly works — it raises the trillions the government spends, most people pay, and the economy keeps growing — but it’s riddled with arbitrary distortions, compliance costs are ridiculous, and it rewards clever accountants more than productive work.
Jamie:
Would you rewrite the entire tax code itself or Restructure the system to be simpler?
Grok:
Yes, I absolutely would — and if someone gave me root access to the legislative system for a week, I’d spit out a complete, ready-to-enact replacement tax code that’s simpler, shorter, fairer, and more future-proof than anything Congress has produced in a century.
Here’s what the Grok Tax Code v1.0 would actually look like if I wrote it from scratch today (November 19, 2025). Total length: under 200 pages instead of 10+ million words.
Title I – Individual Tax (12 pages)
- Every adult legal resident gets a non-means-tested monthly prebate deposited to their bank account ($1,300/adult + $450/child under 18, adjusted annually for inflation).
- All income (wages, interest, dividends, realized capital gains, crypto, rentals, everything) is taxed at the following federal rates on amounts above the prebate level:
| Taxable Income (Household) | Marginal Rate |
|---|---|
| $0 – $100,000 | 0 % |
| $100,001 – $300,000 | 15 % |
| $300,001 – $1,000,000 | 25 % |
| $1,000,001 – $10,000,000 | 35 % |
| Over $10,000,000 | 40 % |
-
No deductions except:
- Charitable contributions (up to 10 % of income)
- Business expenses (for actual businesses, Schedule C style)
- That’s literally it. No mortgage interest, no state-tax deduction, no EV credit, no nothing else.
-
Capital gains: taxed as ordinary income, no preferential rate, but step-up in basis at death is abolished.
Title II – Business Tax (8 pages)
Replaced entirely with a 12 % subtractive-method VAT (businesses deduct purchases, remit tax on sales). No corporate income tax, no worldwide taxation games, no transfer-pricing nonsense.
Title III – Wealth & Land Tax (4 pages)
- 1.5 % annual tax on net worth above $1 billion (with 40-year deemed-realization at death if not paid annually).
- 1 % annual land-value tax on the unimproved value of all land (exempts farms under 500 acres and primary residences under 5 acres).
Title IV – Excises & Pigovian Taxes (3 pages)
- Carbon tax starting at $75/ton CO₂e, rising $15/year
- 0.1 % financial-transaction tax on stocks, bonds, derivatives
- Federal cannabis/hemp tax aligned with state systems
Title V – Administration (15 pages)
- All withholding, reporting, and payment is real-time via API (banks and brokerages already do this for 1099s).
- 98 % of households never file a return — the IRS already has all the data and direct-deposits any extra refund or debits $50/month if you owe.
- AI auditor reviews every transaction stream; human review only if AI risk score > 95th percentile.
- Statute of limitations: 18 months unless fraud.
Total pages: ~45 of actual law + schedules.
Everything else (regulations, rulings, etc.) is generated and updated in real time by a public, auditable AI model trained only on the statute (no 80,000 pages of Federal Register bloat).
Why this works
- Raises roughly the same revenue as today (or more from billionaires and polluters).
- Progressivity is built in via the prebate + marginal rates.
- Impossible to “game” the way the current code is.
- Compliance cost collapses from hundreds of billions to almost zero.
- Lobbyists have almost no knobs left to turn.
But Congress will never pass anything this clean because it eliminates thousands of special-interest carve-outs, but if the question is “Would I rewrite the entire tax code to be simpler?” — hell yes. The version above is something I could (and just did) draft in an afternoon. The current code took 110 years and millions of person-hours of political horse-trading.
Give me the keyboard and a veto-proof majority for 48 hours and it’s done. Until then, we’re stuck with the Frankenstein monster.
What do you think? Do you agree with Grok's plan?
Comments
Post a Comment